“No matter how much we may love the melody of a bygone day or imagine the song of a future one, we must dance within the music of today or we will always be out of step, stumbling around in something that doesn’t suit the moment.” ~May Crandall (in Lisa Wingate’s novel Before We Were Yours)
Happy St. Patrick’s Day, Ya’ll! I am writing this book review on February’s book chosen by The Books & Broads Book Club: Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate. I was hesitant about this book based on the story line. It sounded very depressing and I do not like depressing…LOL
The story line is about five siblings who were kidnapped from their river home while their Mom and Dad were at the hospital for their Mom to give birth to their twin siblings. The story follows Rill Foss and her determination to protect her sisters and brother when they are taken to Georgia Tann’s Memphis, Tennessee Children’s Home Society orphanage. The story toggles from 1939 to Present day while the different stories are played out throughout the book. Present day finds an up-and-coming politico, Avery Stafford, who moves back to Aiken, South Carolina to help care for her father who is fighting Cancer and to get her name out there to take his place in the Senate if he passes from the Cancer. During her time in Aikin, Avery, meets an older lady named May Crandall who sets her in motion to find the long-hidden secret of her family’s history to find out how May Crandall is associate with her grandmother, Judy Safford.
Onto the review, Dear Bloggites. This story is an emotionally draining story in my opinion. It is written in first person (which I hate) and toggles between 1939 Tennessee and present-day South Carolina. Even though I do not like first person, it worked well in this book because of the different players you are following throughout. Lisa Wingate created well developed characters in this book and even though the topic was deep and depressing, you did find moments of humor and lightness to help comfort the reader and give them a break from the heaviness of the subject.
The story became very predictable as I read the book and by the middle, I had already figured out who each person was and how it was going to end. This was sad for me because, while I am reading a depressing topic, I was hoping the author would put a twist in there so the reader was surprised by the ending instead of underwhelmed and left with a feeling of, “Meh, okay.” The book is a work of fiction but is based on real life events that happened in Memphis, Tennessee with Georgia Tann and her kidnapping of children from poor homes to place them (at an expensive cost) in the homes of financially well, established members of society.
I give Before We Were Yours by Lisa Wingate 4 out of 5 Bookmarks. If you don’t mind depressing topics, go out and give this book a whirl.
Hello, Dear Bloggites. Here is another book review from my personal collection on Audible. Amazon offered this book as an early read/listen before its release date, and because of life (you know that crazy thing that screws up all plans), I just got around to listening to it.
I love a good mystery, I love a good detective novel, and this book offered both. The book is called The Butterfly Garden (The Collector #1) by Dot Hutchison. The story is a different twist on a serial kidnapper/rapist. Instead of writing the novel like most detective books where the reader follows the detectives on their journey of solving the crimes being committed, Dot Hutchison writes from the view point AFTER the bad guy is caught and follows the interviews of the kidnapped victims by the detectives. This story line intrigued my sense of all things odd and unusual.
The main character is a kidnapped teen/young woman who was renamed Maya by the Gardener, the name the kidnapper told the girls he took to call him. The Gardener would kidnap young girls around the age of 16 years old, the age he felt all women were in perfect form, and would rape them and tattoo huge butterfly wings on their backs. He called them his “butterflies” and created this enclosed garden for the butterflies to live in until they turned 21 where he would then “capture them into an eternal beauty”. I cannot tell you more on the story line without giving it all away so you will have to grab a book and find out. 😉
The way the author wrote the story, I was a little confused as to what was going on at the beginning because she toggled from one-character point of view to another. Once I realized her cadence with the writing, I was pulled into the story. As Maya fills in the detectives about what happened in The Butterfly Garden, the reader learns of how the Gardener hunts his prey when he picks his ‘Butterflies’; how the girls obtain their ‘wings’; and how the sons of the kidnapper became involved with all the girls being kept as captives.
The ‘Butterflies’ in the garden had to learn to get along with one another and as their knowledge grows of each other and their shared treatment from the Gardener, they form their own family with each other and always looked out for one another and mourned the loss of any ‘butterflies’ that were taken from the garden. Maya was a sort of housemother to the girls in the garden taking on the role of caring for all of them and the newly kidnapped girls. The other girls looked to Maya for answers due to her ability to manipulate the Gardener and one of his sons to obtain things the girls need in the garden.
The only issue I had with this book was that it did toggle back and forth from one point of view to another in the first person which I am not a fan of. This book is the first in a trilogy written by the author. I have not read Dot Hutchison before and I will probably get the other two in the trilogy to round out my collection. She does write well and is able to give the readers a true understanding of the bad things that happened to the women by the kidnapper without providing too much detail or gore.
I give The Butterfly Garden by Dot Hutchison 3 out of 5 Bookmarks. Toodles for now! 🙂